In our eighth installment of Absurd Fan Theories, Madelaine Petsch joins us to ponder some serious—and not-so-serious—fan theories before Riverdale‘s return. We all know Cheryl Blossom’s love interest will be revealed tonight, so we tried to see if we could get Petsch to slip. Will Cheryl Blossom and Toni Topaz be that slow-burn haters-to-lovers couple? You’ll have to watch and see. But whatever you do, do not turn your back on Chic, and never, ever suggest to Petsch that Cheryl Blossom and Archie Andrews may secretly be twins.
Advertisement – Continue Reading Below
Riverdale returns tonight at 8 P.M. EST on the CW.